13:09
It’s a sad indictment of our political discourse that I have to preface my response with this caveat before I express my opinion, but nonetheless I shall: I am firmly of the left. Ultra-left, in fact. But this is a profoundly base and frankly idiotic argument which reveals the complete lack of credible intellectual thought on the left when it comes to the financial crisis.
We did not operate in a halycon economic climate before banking deregulation. Deregulation is what caused the crisis, but only because deregulation was the solution to the previous crisis, caused by labour power making increasingly destructive (to capital) inroads into capital accumulation. This current crisis is a hangover from the crushing of organised labour. My point is, bankers are not some seperate part of the capitalist economy. Removing ostenstatious excess from the banking sector would not fix our economy.
The moderate left, specifically Labour, have to accept that for the past 15 years our political and economic system has been underpinned by tax incomes from banking. What Hundal won’t accept, either because of his membership of the Labour Party or because he can’t grasp the facts, is that Labour played a fundamental role in using the income from taxes on financial services to engage in systematic wage repression for working people in Britain, purposefully building the financial sector in order to do so.
Your party, Sunny, systematically took apart what remained of British manufacturing, recklessly deregulated financial services and purposefully built a welfare-dependent class in a policy of wage repression aimed at producing not socially-just growth but fast, politically expedient pseudo-growth. K-stripping and banker-bashing is tokenism of the worst kind. Our social ills are not based around these symbolic fripperies but are based on the material poverty and inequality which our entire political system has encouraged for 30 years.
The material poverty of working-class people (which I would say is most of us today, on short or non-existent contracts, with little job security, high credit dependency and little in the way of labour rights) is matched only by the intellectual poverty of our political and commentariat class. This stuff is facile, Sunny, supremely facile. You are lost in a short-term world of polls and electoral politics, whipping up public opinion rather than dealing with the serious problem we’re in. We’ve built ourselves into a corner, economically, and we have no plan for any way out.
"
